Free Shipping on orders over $75 (Excl. Sensory Toys)

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

New Plush & Toys

113 Results

Clear filters
A set of three baby reindeer squishy toys by Top of the World, shown next to their pink holiday-themed packaging. The set includes one pink reindeer, one brown reindeer, and one mint green reindeer, all with cute red noses and antlers.
Three squishy baby reindeer squish toys in pink, brown, and mint green with red noses
Sold out

Baby Reindeer Top Trenz

$10.00

Glitter gel-filled squishy duck face cube toys in purple, blue, and green with orange beaks

Sugar Swaps Duck Cubes Orb

$10.00

1 color
Sugar Swaps Sheep Sea Slug squishy toys in pink, blue, purple, green, and yellow glitter
Four glittery squishy axolotl toys in teal, yellow, pink, and purple colorways

Sugar Swaps Sheep Sea Slugs Orb

$10.00

1 color
Sugar Swaps Onesies Babies Luxury Edition Orb

Sugar Swaps Onesies Babies Luxury Edition Orb

$10.00

1 color
Six glittery squishy balloon dog toys in blue, pink, orange, yellow-green, green, and purple
Squish Mania squishy balloon dog toys in blue, pink, orange, and purple glitter

Sugar Squish Balloon Dogs

$10.00

1 color
Four glittery bear figurines in pink, yellow, blue, and purple on a white background.

Squeezy Sugar Bears

$7.00

1 color
Four glitter-filled squeeze goose toys in orange, pink, purple, and green with white feet and orange beaks

Sugar Squish Goose Squishy Streamline

$10.00

1 color
Yellow foam squishy butter stick toy with blue salted butter label text
Hand squishing a yellow butter slime stick, showing stretchy malleable texture

Squish Butter Stick

$10.00

1 color
Yellow cheese toast shaped slow-rise squishy toy with red speckled surface
Hand squishing yellow speckled cheese toast squishy toy with brown base

Squish Cheese Toast

$12.00

1 color
Orb Easy Sqweezy Super Cheesy yellow squishy toy in retail packaging box

Super Sqweezy Cheese Stress Toy – Viral Squish Sensation Orb Toys

$13.00

1 color
Easy Sqweezy Cake Orb

Easy Sqweezy Cake Orb

$18.00

ORB Sugar Swaps Onesies Babies Sweethearts mystery squishy sensory toy in pink blue or purple
ORB Sugar Swaps Onesies Babies Sweethearts mystery squishy sensory toy in pink

Sugar Swaps Onesies Babies Sweethearts Orb

$10.00

1 color
Top Trenz Super Duper Sugar Squishy

Top Trenz Super Duper Sugar Squishy

$11.00

1 color
Top Trenz Cupcake Sugar Squisher

Top Trenz Cupcake Sugar Squisher

$11.00

1 color
Taba-licious Golden Paw Limited Edition

Taba-licious Golden Paw Limited Edition

$8.00

1 color
Hand squeezing a jumbo rainbow multicolor paw print squishy toy with pink pads

Taba-Licious Jumbo Paws Orb

$15.00

1 color
Load more